Showing posts with label Public Debt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Public Debt. Show all posts

Burden of Public Debt, Sacrifice Imposed on the Taxpayers

The burden of public debt refers to the sacrifice imposed on the taxpayers with the increase in taxation to serve the debt, and the adverse effects on the economy as a whole (like reduction in capacity to consume, reduction in production of high quality goods and services by private sector, increase in price level, increase in inequality of income, inter-generation transfer of burden, outflow of national assets in case of foreign debt, etc.)

The burden is interpreted as financial or direct and real or indirect. Increase in tax level transfers some income of people to government, and the loss in income of people is the financial or direct burden. The other adverse effects on the economy, as mentioned above, are the real or indirect burden.

Related Topic:

However the burden of public debt is determined by the facts as whether it is productive or unproductive / dead-weight debt, whether is internal or external, and the economic situation. Public debt for unproductive purposes is definitely a burden. But that for productive purposes may not be a burden if it is utilized in an effective way. Even the debt for productive purposes will have a burden in the form of increase in price level at least the gestation period. It is said that the internal debt will have no net financial burden to the economy as there will be just transfer on income within the economy. But, the external debt will be a burden as the debt repayment transfers national income to foreign creditors. The debt will not be a burden in a situation of recession or depression and even in an inflationary situation (if it is raised out of the income that is most likely to be used in more consumption). And also, in case of developing countries, the debt used for development purposes will not be a burden; rather it helps in mobilizing financial resources to exploit the un-utilized natural and human resources.

Burden of public debt is also interpreted with its effect as increasing inequality in income. This is why, mostly the holders of government securities are the middle and upper income class in the society and revenue for debt servicing is contributed by all groups in the developed countries and relatively more by the low income groups in the underdeveloped countries. 

The burden is also in the form of inflation. Borrowing from most of the sources, other than the individuals and private organizations, leads to increase in money supply and monetary income of people causing increase in demand. Along with this the government also increases demand. The combined effect will increase the total demand in the economy. But to improve the supply situation it takes certain time. So at least until the gestation period there will be inflation in the economy. 

There are controversial opinions regarding whether it will be a burden to the present generation or the future. On view argues that since the present generation will be deprived of the availability of goods and services as resources will be diverted towards government expenses, the present generation will bear the real burden. Whereas the future generation will bear the financial burden with increase in taxes for debt servicing.


You may also like this:

Sources of Public Debt: Internal and External Sources

Governments may raise public debt from both the internal and external sources. The effects of public debt are determined also by the sources and its size. The sources of public debt are as follows.

Related Topic:

A. Internal Sources

  1. Individuals and Private Organizations - Individuals and private organizations provide loans to government with the purchase of securities like bonds and treasury bills. They provide loans reducing consumption, diverting savings accounts and corporate securities, and out of the funds that would remain idle. This source of debt normally does not exert inflationary pressure, except that from the idle funds, as there will be just a transfer of purchasing power from public to the government and no more money supply.
  2. Financial Institutions – Financial institutions, other than the commercial banks, like Provident Fund, Insurance Companies, Finance and Investment Companies, Co-operatives, Mutual Funds, etc. are the important source of public debt. These institutions normally provide loans to government to reduce their cash-holdings to earn some interests, for the safety of funds and to maintain liquidity. Normally, these institutions prefer to invest on government securities in a situation when there is no sufficient for loan advancements on other activities. Borrowing from this source is likely to inflationary as the funds would not have been spent if it was not loaned to government.
  3. Commercial Banks – Commercial banks provide loans to government out of the excess cash reserves and by credit creation. Like other financial institutions, the commercial banks also provide loans to government in a situation when there is no sufficient demand for bank credit. Borrowing from commercial banks increases money supply in the economy, and is likely to exert inflationary pressure in the economy. 
  4. Central Bank – The Central bank is the lender of the last resort to the government. The central bank, as being the monetary authority of the government, is responsible to manage the public debt on behalf of the government out of its reserve funds and by credit creation against the government securities. bullions and foreign exchange reserves. Borrowing from the central bank has double-fold possibility of credit creation leading to excess money supply in the economy leading to inflation.

External Sources 

Normally, public debt from external sources is raised to finance the development projects and to manage the problem of deficit in the Balance of Payments. Whatever be the sources, borrowing from external sources is likely to exert more inflationary pressure, at least until the gestation period of the projects financed from these sources. The external sources are: 
  1. Foreign Nationals and Private Organizations – Government may borrow from this source by issuing its securities in the international financial market.
  2. Donor Governments – Normally the developed countries’ governments provide loans to the developing countries for development projects in the form of foreign aids.
  3. International Financial Institutions - The international financial institutions like World Bank, IMF, UNCDF, IFC, and ADB, etc. provide loans to governments to finance development projects and to manage the BOP problems.
  4. Funds of Some Countries and Business/Economic Forums – Governments may borrow from the funds created by some countries and business or economic forums like Saudi, Kuwaiti, and OPEC funds.

You may also like:

Public Debt: Concept and Need for Public Debt

Public Debt: Concept

The practice of raising public debt by the state to finance government expenditure started only since 19th. Century. But the royalties used to borrow on their personal goodwill even since ancient times. These days government borrowing has been almost a normal method of financing government expenditure.

J.L.Hansen, “Public debt is the debt owned by a government to people and institutions within its own borders and/or to foreign creditors.”
Philip E. Taylor, "Government debt arises out of borrowing by the treasury from banks, business organizations and individuals. The debt is in the form of promises by the treasury to pay back the holders of these promises a principal sum and interest on the principal."

Public debt is raised internally by floating the securities like bonds and treasury bills, and overdrafts from the central bank. Externally, it is raised from foreign individuals and organizations, donor governments and international financial institutions. Normally, government borrowing is voluntary in nature, but sometimes it may be coercive or with some influence.

Generally, the classical economists were against public debt. They strongly believed on the laissez-faire policy, and so favored minimum size of the government as far as possible to them. Government borrowings is mostly unproductive, inflationary and burdensome. However, they approved debt financing in the productive projects called as the self-liquidating projects. According to Musgrave, "The self-liquidating projects may be defined as investment on public enterprises that provide a fee or sales income sufficient to serve the debt incurred in their financing. It can be defined in a broader way as expenditure on projects that increase future income and the tax-base. Such projects permit serving of the debt incurred in their financing without requiring an increase in the future level of tax-rates.”

The Keynesian view after the 1930’s Great Depression advocated the need for the use of public financial operations as fiscal policy for maintaining economic stability. To them borrowing may not necessarily be unproductive, inflationary and burdensome always. It is accepted as the best option in a period of depression, and to some extent even to control inflation. According to Lerner, government should borrow only when it wants to make people hold more bonds in place of money. The desirability or otherwise of public borrowing should be judged in terms of its effects on aggregate demand and the economic situation.

The modern view is concerned about its importance in raising and mobilization of financial resources, its management, and relationship with the monetary policy. It has been accepted that debt financing beyond the limit is certain to invite severe economic problems.

Need for Public Debt

Borrowing by the state has been a normal method to finance public expenditure in both the developed and developing countries. In different situations or for different purposes public debt is raised.
  1. To manage current budget deficit: Governments do not have large accumulated reserves or cash balances to meet any current budget deficits. Normally, it is said that the regular expenditure should be financed from revenue sources. But due to many reasons sometimes income from revenue sources may not be sufficient to meet even the regular expenditure as required. Besides, the unexpected emergencies like fire, floods, famines earthquakes and other natural disasters necessitates a large amount of government expenditure for rescue and relief works. In such situation governments are compelled to borrow.
  2. To meet war expenses: Borrowing to finance wars is in practice since ancient times. In modern times, the cost of warfare has been tremendously increased with the development in war technology and techniques. In a situation of war, income from revenue sources will not be sufficient to meet war expenses. Besides, in such situation, economic activities generally decreases leading to low level of national income and low yield from taxation sources. In such situation it is not desirable to increase rate of taxes beyond desirable limits which may create serious socio-economic and even political problems in the country. So, it is better and convenient for government to borrow in a warfare situation.
  3. To maintain economic stability: The idea of compensatory finance and functional finance has recognized the importance of borrowings to maintain economic stability. In a situation of depression. Government is to increase its expenditure, mainly by borrowings, to increase effective demand in the economy. To control inflation, government is to borrow out of the peoples’ fund which is likely to be used for increasing consumption expenditure. At the same time, the borrowed money is to be invested on production of goods and services by itself or private sector, Besides, government may borrow from external sources to manage trade deficit.
  4. To promote the rate of economic growth: One of the main constraints in the process of economic growth in the developing countries is lack of sufficient investment resources. To exploit or utilize the potentiality of natural and human resources, it is necessary to make a significant investments on them. For this, the savings of individuals and private corporate bodies can be increased voluntarily by borrowings with attractive monetary benefits. Borrowing from banking and financial institutions including central bank, is needed for productive use of unused or idle resources. Besides, borrowing from external sources in a wise way and effective investments helps in increasing productive capacity of the economy and national production.
  5. To manage the problem of Balance of Payments: In a situation of deficit in the balance of payments, government may borrow from external sources for funding the import requirements.

You may also like: