Showing posts with label Project Appraisal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Project Appraisal. Show all posts

Revisiting Feasibility Study

The feasibility study severs as the starting point for appraisal. Al the aspects of feasibility are carefully revisited
  1. Technical Appraisal: Alternative technical solutions, processes, engineering and design requirements, technical specifications, technical risks and uncertainties, local resource availability, size, scale of operations, layout, location and geology are summarized and assessed.
  2. Economic Appraisal: Economic assessment is in terms of worth of the project to the society. The costs and benefits of the project are assessed and summarized. The criteria used for assessment are:
    • Comparison of benefits and costs
    • Cost-benefit ratio
    • Internal Rate of Return (IRR)
    • Net Present Value (NPV)
  3. Marketing Appraisal: Factors such as project capacity, market demand, market coverage, demand forecast, estimated revenue, marketing programme, competition and ability to satisfy customers are summarized and assessed.
  4. Management Appraisal: Important features of project organization and management, institutional relationships, management capacities and limitations and impact of stakeholders on the project are summarized and assessed.
  5. Environmental Appraisal: The positive and adverse environmental impacts of the project are summarized and assessed.
  6. Financial Appraisal: Factors such as capital requirements, sources of funds, projected cash flow, profitability, and the project's capacity to meet financial obligations are summarized and assessed. Sensitivity analysis is done to test the effects of changes in variables such as cost, price and time on the project's ability to achieve objective. Ratio analysis is done to assess liquidity and profitability. The effect of inflation is assessed.

Project Appraisal

Appraisal is the evaluation of the overall ability of the feasible project to succeed. It  is done after the feasibility study of the project has been completed. The aim is to consider and compare the possible feasible projects and select the best that meets the objectives.

Appraisal is done systematically to provide an overall assessment of the project's likelihood for success. It answers the following questions:
  • Will be project as designed meet its objectives?
  • How does the project compare with other competing projects? This question applies if more than one project has been found feasible.
The primary function of appraisal is to evaluate a project's ability to achieve its objectives. For a private project, the objective is profitability. For a public project, the objective is socio-economic development in the country through economic growth, employment, poverty reduction etc.